The actual senate is about having a council of citizens which has functions in the government with high deliberative compared to the Hamilton’s senate is about having lower quota in each states assigning them to their designated seats without having equality.
Alexander Hamilton’s vision for the Senate, as articulated in his writings and during the Constitutional Convention, differed in several significant ways from the actual structure and function of the Senate as established by the U.S. Constitution. Here are the main differences:
Hamilton's envisioned Senate was intended to be more aristocratic and stable with life terms and significant influence, while the actual Senate features elected representatives with limited terms, ensuring greater accountability and democratic representation.
1. Term Length:
- Hamilton’s Vision: Hamilton advocated for senators to serve for life, similar to the British House of Lords.
- Actual Senate: Senators serve six-year terms, with elections staggered so that approximately one-third of the Senate is up for election every two years.
2. Mode of Selection:
- Hamilton’s Vision: Senators would likely have been appointed, either by state legislatures or some other method that insulated them from direct public influence.
- Actual Senate: Initially, senators were chosen by state legislatures. The 17th Amendment, ratified in 1913, changed this to direct election by the people of each state.
3. Purpose and Role:
- Hamilton’s Vision: Hamilton saw the Senate as a stabilizing force in government, providing continuity, experience, and a check against populism and the potential excesses of the House of Representatives.
- Actual Senate: While the Senate does act as a stabilizing force, it is also designed to represent states equally, regardless of population size, balancing the interests of smaller states against larger ones.
4. Aristocratic vs. Democratic Elements:
- Hamilton’s Vision: Hamilton’s model leaned towards an aristocratic element, where senators would be part of an elite ruling class with significant influence and less susceptibility to popular whims.
- Actual Senate: The Senate, although originally somewhat insulated from direct democracy, is now directly accountable to voters, ensuring a more democratic process.
5. Size and Representation:
- Hamilton’s Vision: Specific details about the size were not Hamilton's primary focus, but the emphasis was on a smaller, more exclusive body.
- Actual Senate: The Constitution established two senators per state, creating a balance between large and small states and ensuring each state’s equal representation.
Summary
Hamilton’s ideal Senate was characterized by life terms, insulation from direct public influence, and a stabilizing, aristocratic role within the government. In contrast, the actual Senate features fixed six-year terms, direct elections, and a design that balances representation between states, ensuring greater democratic accountability.
Which of the following statements best describes French settlers' treatment of Native Americans?
A. French settlers were on friendly terms with Native Americans and they relied on them to provide furs.
B. French settlers had a policy of killing most Native Americans in order to claim new lands.
C. French settlers enslaved Native Americans and forced them to work in mines and on farms.
D. French settlers ignored the local native population unless they interfered with the fur trade.
Why did small states like the new jersey plan?
help asap!!! Why did the United States declare war on Great Britain?
Americans were humiliated by British impressments and Britain’s support of Native Americans.
Americans wanted to empower Native Americans by giving them land in British-held Canada.
Americans believed that the British were attempting to reclaim land in the northern United States.
Americans wanted to expand northward into Canada and remove British settlements there.
The United States declared war on Great Britain due to British impressment, support of Native Americans, and concerns about British intentions in North America. The option (A) is correct.
British impressment of American sailors into the Royal Navy, interference with American shipping, and support of Native American resistance against westward expansion all fueled tensions.
Additionally, Americans were concerned about British intentions in North America, including British support for the Shawnee leader Tecumseh's confederation. These grievances led to the War of 1812, where the United States sought to defend its sovereignty and maritime rights.
This question is not complete, Here I am attaching the complete question:
Why did the United States declare war on Great Britain?
(A) Americans were humiliated by British impressments and Britain’s support of Native Americans.
(B) Americans wanted to empower Native Americans by giving them land in British-held Canada.
(C) Americans believed that the British were attempting to reclaim land in the northern United States.
(D) Americans wanted to expand northward into Canada and remove British settlements there.
What buildings in new york city were hit by the planes on 9/11?
How was Ancient Greece shaped by both isolation and intercultural exchange
It is true that
Ancient Greek was shaped by both isolation and intercultural exchange:
Isolation was due to the geographical conditions of Greece,
it was divided by mountains, rivers and forests forming independent cities
instead of a central monarchy. The fact helped every city progress in their own
unique way and brought out a variety of cultural and intellectual possibilities.
Intercultural exchanges were due to the presence of sea which
allowed them to trade with different cultures like Persian, Frankish states, Ottoman
Empire, Genoese Republic and British Empire. All of these in their various
ways left their influence on modern Greek culture.
What is one major difference between a region and a period
“era” refers to a period of time characterized by events in a chronological order.
“Period” can refer to a short interval of time or a very long interval of time.
A region refers to the geographical areas traditionally associated with a people, society or nation with specific features that are manifested in cultural elements of an area, especially the language and architecture, and with which its inhabitants identify during a historical time determined. On the other hand, the period is the chronological division used to tell and separate the historical time of humanity. The periodization is the study of the General History of Humanity that usually divides human history, by convention and exclusively for didactic purposes
How do the jobs of district federal court judges differ from those judges in the higher courts?
Do you think the catholic church would have done more to help the jews in world war ii? what could it have done? answer
Sumner was physically attacked by Brooks in Congress because ___________________ .
a.
Sumner had attacked abolitionists in Congress.
c.
Sumner had berated pro-slavery, popular sovereignty supporters.
b.
Sumner supported the border ruffians in the Kansas Territory.
d.
Sumner challenged the Fugitive Slave Act and angered pro-slavery supporters.
Answer:
D
Explanation:
To what extent did technology railroads the free enterprise system, the rise of national markets, and population each play a role in making the united states an industrial giant
Final answer:
Railroads significantly accelerated the industrialization of the United States post-Civil War, creating a national market system, enhancing urbanization, and advancing technological innovation, thereby contributing to the rise of the U.S. as an industrial giant.
Explanation:
The Impact of Railroads on Industrialization in the United States
The expansion of railroads was a pivotal factor in transforming the United States into an industrial giant. National railroad mileage saw exponential growth following the Civil War, tripling in the span of a few decades. Railroads enabled the formation of a national market system, promoted urban growth across the East and Midwest, aided in the mechanization of industries such as the textile industry, and facilitated the delivery of vast mineral resources from the Western states.
The rise in industrialization significantly increased both the population and the economic size of the country, leading to increases in urban populations. Advancements such as the telegraph enhanced communication and federal centralization, while new inventions like the electric light bulb and telephone further propelled industrial capabilities and growth. The lure of factory jobs and the necessity for labor also resulted in the immigration of fourteen million people seeking work.
The development of large corporations, such as the Standard Oil Company and the Carnegie Steel Company, through the sale of stocks, was instrumental in raising capital for further expansion. Meanwhile, the Civil War had spurred a manufacturing boom that, following the war's conclusion, transitioned into serving international markets. All these developments, facilitated by the railroads, laid the groundwork for America's economic ascension as an industrial power.
Which statement best describes a disadvantage of indirect democracy over direct democracy?
A: It is not a guarantee that individual voices will be considered.
B: It is inefficient when there are few issues to discuss.
C: It works better for large populations than for small ones.
D: It requires more time and energy from citizens.
Wartime challenges caused th government to take an active role in the economy what steps did the government not take
Who were scalawags and what did they try to accomplish
Answer:
Scalawags were the Southern white who supported the Reconstruction after the Civil War in America. They tried to gain wealth and power after the Civil War in America with the help of the North in the South. Scalawags before the war were not wealthy and not among the planter elite. Some were non-slave owners and struggled with poverty. They supported the reconstruction plan in the South and assisted the blacks in giving them some rights.
The "other half" that Jacob Riis referred to in his 1890 book, How the Other Half lives were to
Answer:
The "other half" that Jacob Riis referred to in his 1890 book, How the Other Half lives were to
Explanation:
How the other half lives: studies among the tenements of New York.
During the 80s of that century, the middle and upper classes of the city ignored the difficult and dangerous conditions of marginalization of poor immigrants.
The work made harsh criticism of the local government and pointed out the difficult living conditions and labor exploitation faced by immigrants, this is how the other half lives, exploited and with little money.
Why did many women in virginia not start a family until their mid-twenties?
What was an effect of the apollo missions?
Early seafaring trade centered on the?
Final answer:
Early seafaring trade in the sixteenth century was predominantly focused on the Indian Ocean, with European powers such as Portugal seeking maritime routes to Asia, thus triggering the start of global trade and the era of globalization.
Explanation:
Early Seafaring Trade
Early seafaring trade during the sixteenth century prominently centered on the Indian Ocean, as European explorers like the Portuguese began seeking maritime routes to enhance trade with Asia, spurred by the fall of Constantinople and the obstruction of overland trade routes. The desire for goods such as spices, silk, and porcelain fueled the search for sea passages to avoid the costly and lengthy Silk Road and Muslim intermediaries. The rise of the Portuguese in maritime exploration marked the beginning of global trade as they ventured along the African coast and reached India by sea, paving the way for subsequent European nations to expand their seafaring ventures.
Trade in East Africa also played a crucial role in the Indian Ocean trade network, connecting it with the Middle East, China, and Southeast Asia. With strategic geography, seasonal monsoon winds, and the ideal dhow ships, the East African city-states on the Swahili coast flourished as trade hubs, linking people and commodities across three continents.
According to Steffens, what was the purpose of muckraking journalism?
The __________ is an advisory group, selected by the president and approved by congress, whose major function is to help the president execute the laws and assist him in making decisions. science forums
The Paleolithic, Mesolithic, and Neolithic eras occurred during which age?
Answer:
The Paleolithic It is the longest period of the existence of the human being (in fact it covers 99% of it) and extends from about 2.59 million years ago (in Africa) until about 12 000 years ago. It is, together with the Mesolithic / Epipaleolithic (transition phases) and the Neolithic, the so-called Stone Age, named because the elaboration of lithic tools has served archaeologists to characterize it (as opposed to the later Metal Age). Mesolithic is the term used to summarize the period of prehistory that serves as a transition between the Paleolithic and the Neolithic. The Mesolithic would begin with the transition from the Pleistocene to the Holocene, about 12,000 years ago, and end with the appearance of the modes of life producers, whose chronology varies greatly from one region to another and from one continent to another: while in the Middle East the neolithization emerged over 9000 BC. C., to Scandinavia and certain areas of Atlantic Europe did not reach until 4000 a. C. The Neolithic is the last of the periods in which the Stone Age is considered divided. Agriculture and livestock began to be practiced in different places on the planet independently and on different dates. The first region where there is evidence of the transition of some hunter-gatherer societies to others of producers was the Middle East, around 8500 BC. C., from where it spread to Europe, Egypt, the Middle East and, perhaps, South Asia. Very shortly after, the production processes developed completely independently in northern China in the valleys of the Yellow River and the Yangtze (7500 BC). In New Guinea there was also an early development independent of horticulture, as some evidence suggests that it was around 7500 BC. C., although this date is still insecure. In Africa, the first regions where the Neolithic transformations occurred were the Sahara, Sahel and Ethiopia, although there is a divergence of opinions: some authors believe that there could have been some kind of influence from Asia and others consider that the development was independent since they were domesticated local plant species.The religious rebirth that occurred as a result of the religious tolerance that spread through the middle colonies in the mid-eighteenth century was known as:
according to the lesson, why did reagan have the united states invade grenada? american college students were protesting there. acts of piracy were originating from the island. communist leaders were making inroads there. foreign nations were trying to take it over.
The answer is C hope this helps.
Answer:
communist leaders were making inroads there.
Explanation:
In 1983, the island Grenada was known to be assisting communist Cuba, which was an enemy of America. As a consequence, president Ronald Reagan sent 2,000 troops and defeated the Cuban government, while only 18 Americans died. Finally, Reagan claimed it was important to protect the future of US security from the communists.
Which fact BEST reflects how the colonist's experience under British rule impacted government in America following the Revolution?
Answer: the answer is c
Explanation:
Which best describes the three levels of Sumerian society?
A. Priest; rulers and government officials; merchants, artisans and peasant farmers
B. rulers, officials, and priest; lesser priests, scribes, merchants, and artisans; peasant farmers
C. The king; Priest; officials, scribes, merchants, artisans, and farmers
D. High priest and kings; officials; merchants and peasants
The only large animals left in the americas after 8000 bce that was suitable for carrying heavy loads was the _____________.
William Penn established the mid-Atlantic colony of Pennsylvania mainly because
loss in the war with the Dutch
failure to take over the Massachusetts Bay Colony.
desire to create a logical, well-organized, religiously tolerant colony.
wanted a government where all citizens could participate.
Answer:
desire to create a logical, well-organized, religiously tolerant colony.
Explanation:
Pennsylvania was born as a relifiously tolerant colony, and was founded because its founder and other people were fleeing religious prosecution, because of that they wanted to establish a colony that had religious tolerance and a place to grow, he was a quaker and as a quaker he was not obbeying the obligatory anglican religion for all British citizens, so when the opportunity came and he along with other 200 settlers were granted half of the New Jersey province they took the opportunity to create a province for themselves were there was religious tolerance.
Why does a secularist separation of church and state lead to a state-over-church situation?
How did the writers of the U.S. Constitution adapt the political theories of the enlightenment?
Which minor party’s role in the 2000 presidential election contributed to the defeat of the Democratic party candidate?
the Green Party
the Progressive Party
the American Independent Party
the Libertarian Party
Answer:
the green party
What were some of the main social problems faced by america in the 1950s?