The Seventeenth Amendment to the US Constitution calls for the direct election of all US Senators. This means that the people of each state get to vote to decide who will be their two US Senators. Before this, the legislatures of each state chose the two US Senators from that state with no direct involvement of the average voter.

Why would this amendment be considered a reform? How would it benefit the people?
Even today some people claim that the Seventeenth Amendment was a bad idea. What arguments could be made for reverting selection of US Senators back to the state legislatures?

Answers

Answer 1

The United States did not directly vote for senators during the first 125 years of the federal government. The Constitution, which was adopted in 1788, declared senators elected by state legislatures. The first proposal to amend the constitution and elect senators by popular vote was presented in the House of Representatives in 1826, but the idea did not receive enough support until the 19th century, when several problems related to elections in the Senate became evident. . . Several state laws were paralyzed by the elections of the senators, which made Senate seats remain vacant for months and even years. In other cases, the political machines gained control over state laws and the senators elected with their support were seen as puppets. In addition, the Senate was perceived as the "millionaire's club". That is public service. The rise of the Popular Party, called the Populist Party, motivated the creation of a Senate more responsible to the public.

The Seventeenth The Constitution of the United States (XVII) the direct election of the United States Senate by popular vote. The amendment replaces Article I, Section 3, Clauses 1 and 2 of the constitution, under which the Senate was elected by the State Legislatures. It also alters the method of filling vacancies in the Senate, to be consistent with the method of choice. It was adopted in April 1913.

Answer 2

The Seventeenth Amendment is a reform because it allows citizens to participate directly in the election of representatives. Most who oppose the amendment point to the reassertion of state power in Washington and  restoring checks on federal expansion.


Related Questions

What are some positive effects of tariffs

Answers

a positive effect of tariffs are,

domestic industries benefit from a reduction in competiton, since import prices artificially inflated.

also, since a tariff is a tax,

the government will see increased revenue as imports enter the domestic market.

hope i could help! <3

Answer:

Higher Profits Apex

Explanation:

Which if the following best describes the Wilmot proviso

Answers

'a document about the future of slavery in all territory acquired from Mexico'.

Becasue the Wilmot Proviso put forward a law to ban slavery in states that had been taken over by Mexico in the Mexican War.

Which layers of the earth are made mostly of metals

Answers

i think it might be the inner core


The outer core its made of iron nickel and molten lava

Which Country Did Not Allow United States To Build Panama Canal

Answers

Columbia refused to let the United States build the panama Canal. In response to this, the American government sponsored a Panamanian revolution.

A microfinance institution would most likely offer a loan to an entrepreneur who:

A. lives in a wealthy and developed country.
B. works for a multinational corporation.
C. belongs to a marginalized social group.
D. is openly critical of free trade policies.

Answers

A microfinance group (institution) would loan to an individual who was part of a marginalized social group.

The correct answer is option C. "belongs to a marginalized social group". Microfinance institutions are non-governmental organizations that could follow a bank scheme to provide financial support to the poor. Therefore it is more likely that a microfinance institution would provide a loan to an entrepreneur that belongs to a marginalized group.

Which of the following is NOT a characteristic of mythology?

A.attempts to explain origins and reality

B.supernatural beings, heroes, and ancestors

C.may feature witches and fairies

D.linked to religion

Answers

i think the answer would be A.attempts to explain origins and reality

this is beacuse mythology explains unreal things and theories on make believe. not orgins and reality

if im correct please mark as brainliest :)

Hey there! The answer is going to be A.attempts to explain origins and reality




Mind marking me brainliest. Thank you!


Have an amazing day!

Tutankhamen, also known as King Tut, is MOST well known for which of these?

A) His tomb was found in Greece completely empty in
1922.

B) A very long reign as Pharaoh, dying of a broken leg in 1327 B.C.

C) His tomb was discovered fully intact in 1922 with about 3500 artifacts.

D) His tomb was first discovered by Woodrow Wilson in 1922 in the Valley of the Kings.

Answers

Tutankhamen, also known as King Tut, is MOST well known for which of these?

A) His tomb was found in Greece completely empty in
1922.

Answer:

the answer is b it is not a i did i tried it it said it was b

Explanation:

What turns the north into an economic powerhouse? Who is the man behind it?

Answers

Final answer:

The North became an economic powerhouse primarily due to the Industrial Revolution and contributions from key figures like Andrew Carnegie, John D. Rockefeller, and J.P. Morgan. Technology advancements have also played a significant role in economic growth, along with shifts in labor and focus on human capital development.

Explanation:

The North turned into an economic powerhouse primarily due to the Industrial Revolution and its aftermath, which significantly transformed the manufacturing sector and shifted economic growth. Pivotal figures like Andrew Carnegie, John D. Rockefeller, and J.P. Morgan grew their respective businesses, influencing the country's growth significantly. These enterprising individuals did not inherit wealth but achieved their status through hard work, discipline, and numerous innovative pursuits.

Another crucial factor contributing to the U.S. economic growth is technology. The advancement in technology often contributes more than the growth in human capital and physical capital. Innovative approaches and new ways of doing things have been integral for sustaining growth.

Moreover, countries experiencing an economic upturn have been noted to focus on health and education or human capital development, which modern technology has significantly enabled. The shift in labor from rural to urban areas or manufacturing zones also marks a turning point for many economies, leading to sustainable wage increases in both agricultural and manufacturing sectors, given the successful absorption of surplus agricultural labor into the manufacturing sector.

Learn more about Economic Powerhouse here:

https://brainly.com/question/34172226

#SPJ12

How did the expansion of the roman Empire affect its government?

Answers

The expansion of Roman power throughout the Mediterranean affected many aspects of political life. Conquests meant enslavement of many conquered people, thus expanding the role of slavery in the Roman economy and contributing to the growth of large estates (latifundia) and possibly to economic inequality as well.

Roman expansion and especially the Roman conquest of the eastern Mediterranean changed the character of Roman political power. Having to participate in ongoing warfare and often sacrifice their lives for the republic was an enormous burden on Roman peasants. Meanwhile, the aristocracy accumulated most of the benefits that the expansion brought; they acquired new wealth, slaves, and social contacts. An extensive network of patron-client relationships developed between Roman senatorial families and wealthy provincials.

What changes did the war bring for African Americans

Answers

They were more or less free from slavefy
They had more rights than they did when they were owned and are probably free as well

If you are black but light skin how long should you be outside to get darker?

Answers

You can't the most you can do is get dehydrated

Which of these statements best describes transportation with cities in the early 1800s?

Answers

what are the statements?

C. Ernest Hemingway’s A Farewell to Arms is, perhaps, the best known American novel of WWI. How does Hemingway react to the war, how does he treat the theme of love in a time of war, the contrast between life affirming and death confirming imagery?

Answers

Retreat remains one of the most profound evocations of war in American literature, No sooner does Catherine announce to Henry that she is in mourning for her dead .. Motifs are recurring structures, contrasts

Mark this as brainliest please its right

A Farewell to Arms is a novel that is primarily concerned with war. However, the reactions to the war, both from the authors and from the characters, vary greatly. Most of the characters in the novel are ambivalent about the war. They either care very little about it, they are angry about the destruction or doubtful about the things they will obtain if they win. However, there are some characters that support the war. These characters are naive, not very clever or too immature. This indicates that Hemingway did not strongly support the war either.

Against this backdrop of war, Hemingway discusses the idea of love. Particularly, "true love." Henry and Catherine are able to escape the war, and find solace, in each other. The love, however, takes on the role of distraction and of life-giving power. Finally, it also takes on the role of refuge and salvation, even if just a temporary one.

who did the CSA choose as their first president?

Answers

The first and only President of the traitorous Confederate States of America was Jefferson Davis.

Prior to the Civil War, Jefferson Davis was a Senator representing Mississippi. When the Confederate State seceded and committed treason, they formed a provisional government and named Davis their provisional leader.

Davis was eventually elected President of the traitorous Confederate States of America. Davis was captured in 1865 by the American/Union Cavalry and was held for two years.

He was not tried and was eventually released. He eventually became a hero the revisionary Lost Cause supporters of the traitorous Southern rebellion.

how did the growth of industry in the early 1900s affect union membership?

Answers

Union membership grew and there were more strikes.

What impact did the enlightenment have on society

Answers

Enlightenment impacted society by introducing the idea that mankind could use reason to discover the laws of the world and the rights of mankind. These ideals affected all factions of society, from politics to religion.

Final answer:

The Enlightenment influenced the promotion of democratic principles, contributed to significant political revolutions, and altered the way societies understood authority, which has continued to shape modern governance and individual rights.

Explanation:

Impact of the Enlightenment on Society

The Enlightenment had a profound effect on society and shaped the course of history. It challenged the traditional authority of the monarchy and the church by promoting democratic principles and the idea of a social contract, which suggested that governments derive their authority from the consent of the governed, as proposed by philosophers like John Locke. This revolution in thinking influenced and helped engender the French Revolution as well as the Declaration of Independence of the Thirteen Colonies in America, laying the groundwork for modern democracy. Despite its emphasis on reason and progress, the Enlightenment also unintentionally enabled the development of military technologies leading to bloody wars, and did not prevent the ongoing enslavement or dispossession of marginalized groups.

Furthermore, the Enlightenment catalyzed economic development and the Industrial Revolution by favoring rationalism and an empirical approach to knowledge. However, this shift also led to increased societal inequalities and complex social problems. Still, the legacy of the Enlightenment continues to influence our notions of liberty, legal rights, and governance, proving its enduring importance.

what where the main events in ww1? related to serbia

Answers

Jun 28, 1914. Archduke Assassination. Archduke Franz Ferdinand is assassinated in Sarajevo. ...

Jul 30, 1914. Russia Mobilizes. ...

Aug 4, 1914. World War I Begins. ...

Apr 22, 1915. Germans Fire. ...

May 7, 1915. Lusitania Sinks. ...

Sep 18, 1915. Germany Limits Submarines. ...

Sep 15, 1916. First Tanks. ...

Feb 1, 1917. Submarines Back.


Final answer:

The main events related to Serbia in World War I include the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand by a Serbian nationalist, leading to the Austro-Hungarian invasion of Serbia; Serbia's role in the Balkan Wars; and the entanglement of alliances that escalated the conflict into a global war.

Explanation:

Main Events Related to Serbia in World War I

The assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand of Austria-Hungary by a Serbian nationalist, Gavrilo Princip, in Sarajevo on June 28, 1914, was a catalyst for the outbreak of World War I. This act was born out of a strong sense of nationalist sentiment and the yearning for Slavic independence. Princip was associated with a group whose sentiments were echoed throughout Serbia.

Following the assassination, Austria-Hungary presented an ultimatum to Serbia which was partially accepted. However, Austria-Hungary proceeded with an invasion of Serbia, backed by Germany. As Serbia had a defense treaty with Russia, this action prompted Russia to mobilize its forces, setting off a chain reaction that drew in multiple European powers into a full-blown conflict.

During the war, Serbia also sought to expand its influence in the Balkans and was a founding member of the Balkan League. They initiated the First Balkan War in 1912 against the Ottoman Empire and emerged victorious. However, internal conflicts within the Balkans led to the Second Balkan War in 1913, involving Bulgaria attacking both Serbia and Greece. The drive for Serbian expansion played a significant role in the intricate web of alliances and conflicts that characterized the period leading up to and during World War I.

Why did Precident Franklin D. Roosevelt establish social security?

Answers

The President Franklin D. Roosevelt sang in to law the  Social Security Act in 1935. It was a historical act which guaranteed an income for the  unemployed and retires.

The principal reason to establish social security was to combat unemployed. The Social Security System has remained relatively unchanged since 1935.



This was crafted during a rally for women's rights in upstate New York in 1848, and asserted that women deserved the same rights as men, rights which were guaranteed in both the Declaration of Independence and the U.S. Constitution.

Answers

The Seneca Falls Convention took place in New York in 1848 and was the first convention about women’s rights in the United States.  

During this convention the “Declaration of Sentiments” was written and it described the grievances and demands of women. It encouraged women to fight for their right to equality as a US citizen guaranteed by the Constitution. The Declaration of Sentiments looked for equality of women in politics, religion, education, morals and the right to vote.  


Women's Suffrage Movement was crafted during a rally for women's rights in upstate New York in 1848 and asserted that women deserved the same rights as men,rights which were guaranteed in both the Declaration of Independence and The US Constitution.

The Seneca Falls Convention was the first Women's Rights Convention in the US.It was held in July 1848 in Seneca Falls in New York.The meeting started Women's Suffrage Movement which more than 7 decades later ensured women the right to vote.

China was insulated from the scientific and industrial revolutions occurring in Europe because of itself impose isolation as a result

Answers

parts of the world started developing rapidly while the isolated China could not

China was insulated from the scientific and industrial revolutions occurring in Europe because of itself impose isolation; as a result, the West surged ahead of China while China began its slow decline.

Thousands of years of isolation led to social, political and economic stagnation completely isolated China from the pivotal developments in Europe most notably the scientific and industrial revolution that occurred in the 18th and 19th Century respectively. China's technological and economic supremacy compared to the rest of the world no longer held its position.

(A, B, C, or D Answer Choice.)

"He has made Judges dependent on his Will alone, for the tenure of their offices, and the amount and payment of their salaries."

The U.S. government today reflects the main idea of this quote by

A.) Teaching the children of Americans the only proper way to contact officials
B.) Offering medical care for all Americans affected by war or other conflict
C.) Protecting the right of Americans to free speech and political expression
D.) Implementing three branches of government to prevent abuse of power

Answers

the answer is B.) Offering medical care for all Americans affected by war or other conflict

how were British pushed out of Boston early in the war?


please need help with this question above

Answers

Henry Knox used ox to bring a load of artillery from fort Ticonderoga to Boston. Washington and the army set them up on Dorchester Heights. When they saw the big guns they retreated 9,000 red coats and 2,000 loyalists.

Explain what life was like in early Texas. Help, I have a test about it tomorrow :/ (Brainliest for the fisrt person who answers)

Answers

Between 1846 and 1860 almost all Texan citizens lived on ranches or farms. During that period of time, the number of farms increased from 1200 to roughly 43000. Land was inexpensive and even available, so that many Texans farmed or raised cattle on their own land instead of working for another person. The main activity in farmers lives was the growing of food crops, such as oats, sweet potatoes and wheat, which constituted a major part of their diet. But, it is important to highlight that only few farmers made profit from those food crops. They also produced cotton to be shipped to Europe. In addition to this activities, they also focused on raising livestock, such as milk cows, and chickens to provide food and make profit.

Why where european countries able to conquer so much of the world

Answers

They had better equipment when it came to war and technology while the African's where fierce but the bows and arrows wernt fit enough for there guns
their influence across every inhabited continent. This was not inevitable. In fact, for decades, historians, social scientists, and biologists have wondered: Why and how did Europe rise to the top, even when societies in Asia and the Middle East were far more advanced?

So far, satisfactory answers have been elusive. But this question is of the utmost importance given that Europe’s power determined everything from who ran the slave trade to who grew rich or remained mired in poverty.

Which factor most contributed to the United States becoming a more multicultural society during the late 1700s and early 1800s?

Answers

The factor which most contributes to the United States becoming a more multicultural society was the immigration. Immigrants were generally welcomed in the late 1700s and early 1800s. Despite of the fear that immigrants would alter United States culture and customs, the match between Europeans seeking opportunity and an America in need of people left the immigration door wide open. Between 1783 and 1820, about 250,000 immigrants came to America. After 1820, ships captains had to report on the immigrants they brought to the United States, and since then 67 million immigrants have been admitted to the United States contributing to a multiplicity of cultural, social and ideological beliefs.

Answer: Many Africans were brought to the United States as slaves.

Explanation: Took test, answer correct.

Drag the word to the description it matches.
What did scholars consider the three perfections between the Tang and Ming dynasties?
painting
architecture
calligraphy
poetry
medicine
pottery

Answers

The answer is painting, calligraphy and poetry.

Scholars were the practitioners of Scholasticism, a method of learning which involves critical thought. It developed in Europe from 1100 to 1700s approximately.

Scholars considered painting calligraphy and poetry, taken from the Tang (618–907) and Ming (1368–1644) dynasties, as the three perfections. They explored the interconnection of these three in their artworks and used them as a means to express themselves.  

These form of art were highly estimated, especially calligraphy since it revealed a person's nature or character, regardless of the meaning of the written words.



Which of the following states shares a border with Canada? Arizona South Dakota Idaho Ohio

Answers

Sorry idaho is your answer



Hello there!

The answer here is D. Ohio. Ohio is in the northern area of the US, so it borders Canada.

Hope this helps you, and have a splendid day! ♥

Which of the following was significant event in the spread of Islam
A. The defeat of the Gupta in India
B. The fail of the Sassanian Persian empire
C. The conversion of romans to Islam
D. The growth of Bedouin tribes in Arabia

Answers

The answer it’s letter C

The significant event in the spread of Islam is the fail of the Sasanian Persian empire. Option (b) is correct.

What do you mean by Empire?

A political unit known as an empire is made up of many different nations and regions that is "often established by conquest and divided into a dominant center and submissive peripheries."

Sasanian power growth in the West led to conflict with Rome. Shapur I captured Valerian, the Roman emperor, in a conflict close to Edessa in 260 A.D. The king of Palmyra, a caravan city in Syria, was then given the responsibility of protecting Rome's eastern frontier.

At the same time, a plague had decimated the populace and local government had virtually replaced centralised control. But in one of the most remarkable battles of the Arab Conquest, attackers from the south ultimately brought down the Sassanid Empire.

Therefore, Option (b) is correct. The fail of the Sasanian Persian empire.

Learn more about Empire, here;

https://brainly.com/question/29587302

#SPJ5

HELP FAST!!!!!!!!!!!!

Choose one of these issues to research:

bullying

hunger


Choose one of these formats for your presentation:

letter to a newspaper editor

slideshow presentation


Your presentation should address all the following questions:


What is your chosen issue?

Why is this issue a problem in your state or local area?

What government agencies and citizen groups would likely address the issue? What is the ultimate goal to address this issue? (In other words, how will you know the problem is solved?)

What are the public policy alternatives to address the issue?

What is one positive and one negative outcome for each possible policy alternative?

What is the best plan to get the policy enacted?

How can citizens get involved to help enact the policy?'

Answers

- The issue is bullying and it is going to be a presentation.                                          

                           

                                    Bullying and how to defeat it

  Nowadays, all around the world this action is affecting people of all ages and just in some cases people try to eliminate this. This issue is consecuence of not teaching the people since they are kids, the good values that everybody should know in order to live in society pacefully.

 This matter sholuld be solved but not only by the people that is suffering it, but also the government or any other person that knows a case of bullying, eventhough it does not affect him or hre, should try his or her best to solve this problem and erradicate this issue. Specialists like psychologists and psychiatrists from every state, province or town that suffers this problem should interfere and teach people, from kids to adults, how to respect, help and make other people´s lifes happy instead of ruing them. If people could learn that if we all bring happines and respect to each other´s life, and that if someone is going through a hard situation we give him or her a hand, we would overcome a lot of hard situations easily and we would not be carrying with one heavy bag that makes our lifes harder and that bag is called bullying.

 Bullying should be penalized, if kids do it they should be taught how to respect their partners and if it is necessary private them from some benefits untill they learn. And in case of teenagers and adults, eventhough they should also be taugth how to respect their partners, if it is necessary they should be punished and pay a fine. At first it is going to be hard for familys to punishe their sons, brothers, uncles, cousins or any other member, but when they start to learn how to respect the others and their attitudes change, they will notice that it worth it was worth.

 Citizens and members of any society should inform the authorities if they know of any case of bullying in any environment because there are qualities of life that are being affected and if we want to make this world a better place we have to fight for what we want and teach good values to everybody who does not have them.                          

Answer:

1.

o What is your chosen issue?

        Bullying

o Why is this issue a problem in your state or local area?

Bullying is a problem in my area because, in school, people get bullied for dressing and behaving how they want to. You are supposed to be whoever you want to be. Sadly, students can become mentally broken by bullies' actions, harsh critiques, and cruel words. Bullies can affect kids mentally. Today some adults still have so much trauma that they held on to from when they were just a child. Bullying is a horrible thing and can affect people for a lifetime.

o What government agencies and citizen groups would likely address the issue?

Justice's Civil Rights Division and the Department of Education's Office for Civil Rights

Explanation:

all I have right now

Why would Hawaii have a military significance for the US? (before Hawaii became a state)

Answers

Because of their navy bases I believe..

Other Questions
Which of the following terms best describes three points that all lie in a straight line?A. CollinearB. CongruentC. EqualD. MidpointI would appreciate a description of this as well. *Take math seriously or you gone have to retake this subject* Which of the following is the value of x, in degrees, of DEF triangle shown below Which of the following represent human systems? - Hoover Dam - genetic engineering - volcanic eruptions - the Panama Canal- plate tectonics as a wave moves toward the shore into shallower water, the wave length ________ and its height _________ Tony is standing at sea level. From his location, the angle of elevation of the top of Blue Mountain is 25. Staying at sea level, he walks 200 yards toward the mountain. The angle of elevation of the top is now 30. Find the height of Blue Mountain. Round intermediate results to 3 decimal places and the final answer to 1 decimal place.The height of Blue Mountain is ____ yards Why would nations in Latin America be part of a mostly Arab cartel group known as OPEC? Which principle guides Supreme Court justices to follow precedent when ruling on cases? a. two-year terms b. until the president who appointed him/her is out of office c. four-year terms d. for life Postal carrier can deliver 130 houses and 2.5 hour. At this rate how many hours will it take to deliver 312 at houses What is important about the location George Washington chose for the newcapital?A.) It was not part of any state.B.) It was situated along the frontier.C.) It was part of a large commercial center.D.) It was in the countryside where it was hard to attack. a potter uses 3/5 of a pound of clay to make a bowl. How many bowls could the potter make from 10 pounds What is the range of the data represented by the box plot? What is the factorization of 3x^2-8x+5 Triangle QRS is dilated about the origin by a scale factor of 2/3 to create triangle ABC . Are the two triangles congruent? Quinn is twice as old as karl and four years older than parker. The sum their ages is 21. How old is Parker how are boldface and italics similar? Is the equation below an example of growth or decay y =5(6.8)x The polynomial x^3+8 is equal to What evidence did mary leaky use to understand how early humans thought and felt Edgar purchased a home for $182,100 to home appreciates about 3.5% each year what is the value of the home after 12 years What led to the formation of labor unions during the second industrial revolution? Question 10 options: The desire for employers to revolt against workers. Agricultural sales were quickly outpacing manufacturing sales. Laissez-faire policy caused poor working conditions in factories. Many small towns were beginning to embrace despotism as a means of government. Steam Workshop Downloader