What is Chesterton’s central idea in this essay, and how does he introduce it?

Answers

Answer 1

The essay initially pretends to be a critique of a type of self-improvement book popular at the time, which claimed to tell how to achieve success. These books defined success strictly in financial terms and assumed that if anyone follows certain steps, they will be able to duplicate the accomplishments of wealthy business owners. However, Chesterton’s review of these books includes a broader social criticism. The focus on the definition of success strictly in terms of money is central to his essay. But wrapped around that issue is the idea that each person can or should perceive success on the same terms as a business leader. He illustrates the point by saying a donkey is successful at being a donkey as much as a millionaire is successful at being a millionaire, so there is no point in calling a donkey a failed millionaire or vice versa.


To counter the common assumptions about success, Chesterton describes people in various walks of life and how each might more realistically succeed. In this description, he suggests that these books falsely pretend to help people succeed in their own social circles and encourage people to try to become something they are not and cannot ever be.


Chesterton says these writers tell the ordinary man how he may succeed in his career—if he is a builder, he may succeed as a builder; or if he is a stockbroker, he may succeed as a stockbroker. Chesterton increases his satire at this point, commenting that the authors say a grocer may become a sporting yachtsman; a tenth-rate journalist may become a peer, which is a British nobleman; and a German Jew may become an Anglo-Saxon. Obviously, these transitions are unlikely or even impossible. Chesterton then criticizes the main assumption of these books and the society that produces it. By claiming that average people can follow in the steps of business tycoons such as Rothschild or Vanderbilt, the book's author is taking part in "the horrible mysticism of money," in which people worship the unlikely possibility of achieving great riches.



Answer 2

Final answer:

G.K. Chesterton discusses the paradox of Indian nationalists desiring to establish an independent national identity through the adoption of English governmental models, hinting at a possible identity crisis for India.

Explanation:

G.K. Chesterton's central idea in his essay on Indian nationalism revolves around his perception of nationalists seeking to replicate English governmental models as a sign of a desire to adopt English identity rather than fostering a unique Indian ethos. Chesterton introduces this assertion by stating that the nationalists, who want all trappings of the English government such as the parliament, judiciary, and press, may appear less Indian and not really national in their aspirations.

According to Chesterton, the adoption of English systems and values in establishing a national identity fails to reflect a true sense of national identity. He argues this point by drawing a distinction between native cultures and the influence of colonial powers like England. Chesterton's essay, written for the Illustrated London News, provides insights into his views on imperialism and cultural identity, and it can be surmised that Chesterton fears the loss of unique cultural identities when colonial systems are adopted without question.

In summary, Chesterton's thesis points to the irony and potential issues of a colonized nation seeking independence by adopting the colonizer's governmental systems, suggesting that this might lead to a form of cultural and national identity crisis.


Related Questions

Which type of listening style would be most appropriate for the following scenario?


Your little sister tells you that her pet parakeet, Beau, was just eaten by the neighbor's cat.

informationalcriticalempathic

Answers

empathetic listening 

What are Marita's feelings about the importance of succeeding in school?

Answers

Getting to go to college

In act I, scene III, of Macbeth, the witches address Macbeth as Thane of Glamis. When they foretell that Macbeth will become Thane of Cawdor and king, he is bewildered. Soon after, a soldier informs him that Macbeth is now the Thane of Cawdor. Macbeth wonders to himself whether all the prophecies will come true. Which lines in the excerpt show that Macbeth is on the verge of giving in to temptation, knowing very well that he is considering committing a terrible crime? MACBETH: (Aside.) Two truths are told, As happy prologues to the swelling act Of the imperial theme. I thank you, gentlemen. (Aside.) This supernatural soliciting Cannot be ill; cannot be good:—if ill, Why hath it given me earnest of success, Commencing in a truth? I am Thane of Cawdor: If good, why do I yield to that suggestion Whose horrid image doth unfix my hair, And make my seated heart knock at my ribs, Against the use of nature? Present fears Are less than horrible imaginings: My thought, whose murder yet is but fantastical, Shakes so my single state of man, that function Is smother'd in surmise; and nothing is But what is not.

Answers

Answer:

If good, why do I yield to that suggestion Whose horrid image doth unfix my hair,

And make my seated heart knock at my ribs, Against the use of nature? Present fears

Explanation: i just took the test and got it right

What is a metaphor for people of all different races live together in America

Answers

A melting pot: Where all different races of people come to live together in one country.
Final answer:

The metaphor 'Melting Pot' can be used to describe how people of all different races live together in America, symbolizing the blending of cultures to create a unified society. However, this metaphor can also face criticism for suggesting that distinct cultures should be assimilated into a dominant one.

Explanation:

A suitable metaphor for the concept of people from all different races living together in the United States could be a 'Melting Pot.' This metaphor suggests that people from different backgrounds and races come together to form a single harmonious society, each contributing their unique cultures and experiences.

It signifies the blending and fusing of different elements to create something harmonious or united which aligns with the concept of multiculturalism in America.

Understanding the Metaphor

In a literal melting pot, different metals, or substances are melted to form a new alloy or mixture. In the context of this metaphor applied to society, different races (the elements) live together (melted) and create a new harmonious society (the new alloy or mixture)

This concept is deeply tied to the history of immigration in the United States. However, it is worth noting that while the 'melting pot' metaphor is popular, it is also sometimes criticized for implying that immigrant cultures should be assimilated or 'melted away' into a dominant culture, rather than maintaining their unique identities within a diverse society.

Learn more about melting pot metaphor here:

https://brainly.com/question/32193160

#SPJ6

effects that child abandonment can have on a child ,in particular ,later in their lives.

Answers

For a child his/her childhood is a precious time in terms of memories as well as moral and social training. When a child is abandoned he/she is practically denied the basic training which was their birth right. This sometimes results in the form of an unstable adult who later in their lives can be emotionally dark and will not be able to be the citizen which they need to be. In the worst case scenario such a child can turn towards criminal activities as he/she can held the whole society responsible for the negligence. 

I need help asap please I will appreciate it

Answers

The answer would be choice C because it is the last point of the paragraph.
It would be C, finally.

A is wrong, because it's not the first statement, use first of all in the beginning, not the end.

B is wrong, because second should go, second. Not at the end either.

D is incorrect because however is contradicting all the other statements, just something else to think about, I guess, but in this case, both are in the same topic, so it shouldn't be however.

Which sentence is correct? Dad and I cannot convince Laura to practice because she must first convince she herself. Dad and I cannot convince Laura to practice because she must first convince herself. Dad and myself cannot convince Laura to practice because she must first convince herself.

Answers

i believe the answer is dad and i cannot convince laura to practice because she must first convience herself

the correct answer is: dad and i cannot convince Laura to practice because she must first convince herself

25 Points!! What is Progressive Tense? What does it mean???

Answers

It shows whatever you are talking about still has action

Final answer:

The progressive tense indicates ongoing actions or states of being, using a form of 'to be' plus a present participle (-ing). It captures actions happening at the moment, temporary actions, or planned future events. This tense is crucial for expressing duration and ongoing activities in English.

Explanation:

The progressive tense, also known as the continuous tense, refers to a verb tense that indicates an ongoing action or state of being.

The basic structure for forming the progressive tense is to use a form of the auxiliary verb "to be" (am, is, are, was, were) followed by the present participle form of the main verb, which usually ends in -ing (e.g., "I am running," "She was singing"). This tense is used to describe actions that are happening at the moment of speaking or around a certain time, actions that are temporary, or to describe a future event that has been planned or arranged.

Examples of the progressive tense might include: "We are learning about history," which represents an action happening now, or "I was studying all night," which shows a past ongoing action. The future progressive tense like "She will be starting college next year," illustrates a planned future event. It's important to differentiate between the progressive tense and the simple tense; the simple tense expresses a habitual or regular action, such as "He walks to school."

The progressive tense is vital for conveying time and duration in English conversation and writing. It adds depth to descriptions of activities in progress and provides a more dynamic sense of activity compared to the more static simple tense. As students master English grammar, understanding the progressive tense is key for expressing a wide range of ideas and actions.

What explanations does smith give for the loss of the men and his own capture? What does he include these explanations?

Answers

John Smith argues that the voyage was longer than what they expected, men were tired and theyr arrived to an unknown land. What ism ore, they did not have enough food, they did not have proper shelter so men started to get sick and die. 

Which topic best completes the idea web

Answers

The answer is the Value of volunteering. Counting hours doesn't show the impact of the volunteer work. And as a result, it gives an incomplete picture of the value of volunteers.

Answer:

A : Value of volunteering

Explanation:

edge 2021

0.45 is 1/10 of what

Answers

The answer would be 1/10 of 4.5

The answer would be 1/10 of 4.5

Which word or words complete this sentence​ correctly?

The​ _____________ tools were missing from the shop.
A. mechanic
B. mechanic has
C. ​mechanic's
D. mechanics

Answers

C. Mechanic’s because the mechanic possess the tools
The correct answer is:  [C]:  " mechanic's " .
_____________________________________________________

GUYS HELP ME FIX MY SENTENCE I FEEL IT DOESNT MAKE SENSE!!! 20 POINTS

In conclusion, fast and expensive cars aren't worth it in comparison to the average cheap buses.

Answers

Maybe instead of using 'it' be more specific. What aren't fast and expensive cars worth?
Final answer:

The sentence expresses the view that expensive cars are not worth the cost compared to more economical buses. It conveys a preference for economic and practical benefits over luxury and status. The examples support this by discussing social value, environmental considerations, and societal priorities.

Explanation:

Your sentence can be slightly restructured for clarity and impact. You may consider stating something like this: In conclusion, the allure of fast and expensive cars pales in comparison to the economical and practical benefits of average, cheap buses. This sentence conveys a contrast between two modes of transportation, emphasizing the value and practicality found in the more affordable option.

From the context available, it seems you are attempting to express that economically, buses provide a better value than expensive cars, which may not justify their cost in light of the benefits that cheaper buses offer. This idea taps into broader discussions about cost-effectiveness, transportation efficiency, and socioeconomic factors.

The examples provided touch on various aspects that support this claim. For instance, the argument for subsidized bus rides suggests that there is a social value in recognizing the role of buses. Meanwhile, the text about hybrid cars highlights the trade-offs between environmental benefits and performance issues. Lastly, recognizing the signs of societal priorities, such as the pursuit of faster vehicles, suggests an underlying commentary on consumer choices.

If an author is writing the life story of Abraham Lincoln but it starts it with the moment Lincoln is giving his famous speech the Gettysburg address which narrative technique is the author using?

Answers

Answer:

In medias res.

Explanation:

Starting any narrative in the middle is termed as "in medias res" in literary terms. This form of narrative techniques employs the pattern of starting the story or narration from the middle, then moving in between the past or the present or even the future. This enables the narration to make use of the other times or situations whenever it is required.

If an author starts his writing of the life of Abraham Lincoln from the Gettysburg Speech, he is employing this techniques. And by so doing, he can refer or go back to the early life of Lincoln to show his eventual development.

This really helped me outidk how i could thank you

Answers

By hitting the thanks button and giving 5 stars
Click on the icon that has a heart for a thank you :)

He mentioned to us that their creative director _____ a new campaign to boost the company's image. A - had devised B - has devise C - was devised D - were devising

Answers

B has devised a new campaign to boost the company image
Final answer:

The correct answer is option A - 'had devised', since the sentence discusses a completed past action about the director devising a campaign.

Explanation:

The correct answer to the question "He mentioned to us that their creative director _____ a new campaign to boost the company's image." is option A - 'had devised'. The sentence is talking about an action that was completed in the past, thus we need to use the past perfect tense to describe it. Here, 'had devised' indicates that the devising of the new campaign occurred before the mentioning of it. 'Has devise' is incorrect because it does not match the past tense context of the sentence. Also, the correct form would be 'has devised' not 'has devise'. 'Was devised' and 'were devising' are incorrect too as they portray the director as a passive subject or suggest the action is still ongoing, which is not the case here.

Learn more about Grammar here:

https://brainly.com/question/38412480

#SPJ12

A compound noun may be written as

Answers

A compound noun can be written as a single word, a word with a hyphen, or as two words. 
Final answer:

A compound noun is created when two or more words are joined to form a single noun with a new meaning. It can be written as one word, separate words, or with a hyphen. An example includes 'cattail', formed from 'cat' and 'tail'.

Explanation:

A compound noun is a type of noun that is made up of two or more words that are usually joined together to create a new meaning. These words can be nouns, adjectives, verbs, or prepositions. When two words are combined, they form a single noun with a unique meaning different from the individual words on their own.

There are a few different ways that compound nouns can be written:

As one word, like blackbird from black and birdAs separate words, like ice creamWith a hyphen, like mother-in-law

An interesting example of a compound noun formation involves the letter 't' when it occurs at the junction of both stems, such as in 'cat + tail' becoming cattail.

Learn more about Compound Nouns here:

https://brainly.com/question/134274

#SPJ12

which phrase from the passage most clearly shows an imperialistic attitude?

Answers

D savage lands because hes insulting the lands

The correct answer is C) Savage lands. The phrase "savage lands" clearly shows an imperialistic attitude. Its important to remember that imperialism can be defined as a larger nation growing stronger by taking over poorer or weaker nations. Considering this fact, the use of the phrase "savage lands" shows that author of the passage believes his land is superior to the nation he is talking about conquering.

What is most likely the intended effect of ending the speech this way? Help!

Answers

D it does bring a sense of duty to mind

The correct answer is option letter D (The audience will see that it must have courage because the stakes are high for the whole world). The purpose of the speech “Their Finest Hour” delivered by Winston Churchill to the House of Commons of the United Kingdom in 1940 was to give Great Britain hope during World War II, to achieve perseverance in the people in order to make them gain courage to fight on. In the excerpt presented above from the closing of his speech, Churchill explains that the world is experiencing the atrocities of the World War II and he gives reasons to his requests (“Let us brace ourselves to our duties”) arguing that the world is in jeopardy (“a new Dark Age”/ “we will sink into the abyss”). Moreover, the intended effect of Churchill of finishing this excerpt by providing the reasons to his requests is to make society realize they have to gain courage to fight on, since the whole world has difficult times ahead if they do not fight.

Can someone write an essay for me about cause and effects?? Lol if not it's all good

Answers

the cause is the main event and the affect is the effect of da main event
Final answer:

A cause-and-effect essay explores the reasons for events and their outcomes, such as the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic on society. A well-crafted essay includes a strong thesis, clear introduction, body paragraphs with topic sentences, and a conclusion. Trust in the writing process is key, as all writing can be improved with revision.

Explanation:

Understanding the dynamics of cause-and-effect is a crucial component in writing a well-structured essay. This concept elucidates the reasons (causes) for and the consequences (effects) of a specific action, event, or idea. For instance, a common essay topic could be exploring how the COVID-19 pandemic led to significant changes in societal behavior and business operations. The process involves identifying the factors that contributed to the onset of an event and the subsequent impact it has had. Such analysis can lead to a deeper understanding and generate discussions on potential solutions.



When constructing an essay, it is essential to develop an engaging thesis and build the narrative with an introduction, supporting paragraphs, and a conclusion. Each paragraph should start with a topic sentence and be developed with relevant descriptions, examples, and analyses. A good analogy of this is observed in the model paragraph where the opening of a superstore leads to the closure of local businesses, illustrating the causes and their direct effects on the community.



A comprehensive essay on such a topic should demonstrate the ability to engage in problem-solution reasoning, leverage researched evidence to make strong appeals, and build the author's ethos. Therefore, crafting an essay on the cause and effects of an issue becomes not just an academic exercise, but also an opportunity to explore and understand the complexities of our world and the interactions that define it.



"There is no such thing as bad writers, only writers who give up too soon. There is no such thing as bad writing, just writing in need of revision." This maxim underscores that with perseverance and the willingness to revise, anyone can construct a compelling and insightful essay.

Arguments consist of __________, which are statements that are either true or false.

logic
false premises
sounds
propositions

Answers

Arguments consist of propositions, which are statements that are either true or false.

Answer: D) or the fourth option.

Answer:

Propositions

Explanation:

In logic, propositions are statements that can be said to be either true or false. When a proposition is false, we say that its truth value is false. When the proposition is true, we say that its truth value is true. Propositions are the building blocks of arguments. This is because the fact that they can be proven true or false means that they provide a reliable basis upon which we can build more advanced knowledge.

How does the literary point of view in “The Rescue Mission” affect the reader’s understanding of the story? Use evidence from the text to support your response. Your response should be at least one complete paragraph.

Answers

The Rescue Mission” affect the reader's understanding of the story? Use evidence from the text to support your response. ... The literature the author uses puts the reader in suspense and makes the reader tense which makes the reader want to read the short story more.

Answer:

the author uses literature by putting us in suspense to make us tense, so we keep the story.

Explanation:

hope this helps

If your coworker is upset about a disagreement with her supervisor, you should

A. take the problem to the supervisor.
B. give advice and get involved.
C. listen to her and then return to work.
D. tell the coworker to file a complaint.

Answers

Most likely C because if you get involved the problem will most likely only get bigger.

Which sentence contains the most vivid example of imagery

Answers

What is the sentence about?

Answer: c

Explanation: because im never wrong

In a Toulmin argument, support is composed of the following:

A. Evidence that a writer uses to prove the claim.


B. Assumptions and inferences that the writer takes for granted.


C. Help the author set limits on his/her assertions.


D. Additional evidence to defend the warrant.

Answers

I think the best answer would be A

evidence and proof is important to support your credabilty

Which sentence contains figurative language?



In North Carolina, pine trees grow very tall.


The Florida flowers were shy children who ducked their heads.


Vermont maple trees produce large amounts of syrup.


The Arizona desert contains many green cacti.

Answers

The Florida flowers were shy children who ducked their heads.

The answer to your question would be that the sentence that contains figurative language is the following one: The Florida flowers were shy children who ducked their heads.

The figure of speech used here is personification. Personification is a figure of speech by which, an idea or an animal, is given human characteristics. Therefore, the non-human objects are described in such a way that we feel that they have the ability to act like human beings. In this case, the flowers are described as "shy".

jimmy Carter's presidency was marked by several major national and international crises.

Is this thesis sentence too broad, too narrow, or balanced in scope?

Answers

This thesis looks balanced. However, I will add that I am in middle school and I don't know what your guidelines are for thesis's.

Biped : quadruped :: ostrich :

Answers

the word "bi" means two
the word "quad" means four
so, this means: "biped" is a animal that has about 2 legs and quadruped is a/an animal with four legs

just break down the words into groups, it might come to you!

the word "ostrich" is a large TWO-toed bird
so, your answer MIGHT be a kitten (cat)

good luck on your assignment and enjoy your day!

~MeIsKaitlyn:)

Which sentence below is a complex sentence? a. Because the drama students wanted to perform a classic love story, the teacher selected Romeo and Juliet. c. Gene thought that Finny wanted to buy his car, but Finny, who did not have any money, was just looking. b. It was raining; consequently, the football game was cancelled. d. Tom and Henry played trombones in the school concert last night.

Answers

Gene thought that Finny wanted to buy his car, but Finny, who did not have any money, was just looking. 

Answer:

c.

Gene thought that Finny wanted to buy his car, but Finny, who did not have any money, was just looking.

Explanation:

The word commend is a verb that means to praise formally or officially Write a definition and I identify the part of speech for the word commendations

Answers

If commend means to praise, then a commendation would be a praise or congratulation.

"I commend you." (VERB)

"I will give you my commendation." (NOUN)

In this sentence, a commendation would be a noun (part of speech.)

Answer:

Definition: praise

Part of speech: noun

Explanation:

Commendations refer to the giving of praise, acclaim or encouragement. Besides, it is the plural noun of the verb to commend. For example:

The woman was honored with commendations for helping the detectives with the investigation.

The woman was commended for helping the detectives with the investigation.

Other Questions
What happens to light energy from the Sun when it reaches the surface of Earth?A. The light energy is multiplied when it reaches the plants on Earth.B. The light energy is destroyed when plants areeatenby herbivores.C. The light energy is transformed to chemical energy by photosynthesis.D. The light energy is converted to potential energy by cellular respiration. ________ study of italian street-corner men used participant observation what is the pattern for 2,6,18,54.. How much water should be mixed with 237 ml of ammonia, whose strength is 100%, in order to create a mixture that is diluted to a 75% strength? what was the overall problem with the articles of confederation Phillip gives his sister the taller glass knowing that his mom poured the same amount of milk in his glass, too. Phillip is likely how old?A. Two years oldB. Four years oldC. Six years oldD. Eight years old What is the fundamental difference between a city and county?Counties are established by the state constitution.Cities are established by the state constitution.Counties are created by the legislative branch.Cities are created by the executive branch. what aspect of Kafka's The Metamorphosis can readers most relate to today? Identify which of the given instructions are requirements for a strong essay. Explain the full faith and credit clause. The belief that all nations should enjoy self-determination was expressed in what document? League of Nations charter Treaty of Versailles Fourteen Points speech Fourteen Reservations amendments Which sentence illustrates an internal conflict? A. The lion hunts the antelope. B. Marina attempts to overcome her anger. c. Perry wins a big prize and is happy D. Keith suffers a broken leg at the skate park. What is the slope of the line passing through points A(18,24) and B(16,8)?Enter your answer as a ratio, in simplest form, like this: 42/53 in which section of the Periodic Table are the most active metals located _________ describes best the actions of the puritan leaders in massachusetts bay. a central angle of a circle with radius 16 inches subtends an arc of 19.36 inches. find who invented a practical light bulb that could be used indoors ? what is square root of 8 plus square root of 50 minus square root of 72 Solve the proportion. 2/8 = -30/x One aspect of buddy hollys sound contributed heavily to his "crossover" appeal to diverse audiences Steam Workshop Downloader