Why did the framers include the necessary and proper clause in the constitution?
Answer: The answer is:
For two purposes.
1- to facilitate organization of the government, such as empowering Congress to organize the judicial branch.
2- to help effectuate the other enumerated powers of Congress.
Explanation:
"The Congress shall have Power To ...make all Laws which shall be necessary and proper for carrying into Execution the foregoing Powers, and all other Powers vested by this Constitution in the Government of the United States, or in any Department or Officer thereof".
The Necessary and Proper Clause was included to provide Congress with the flexibility to enact laws needed to carry out its powers, allowing the government to adapt to new situations and maintain a balance of power between the states and the national level.
Explanation:The Necessary and Proper Clause was included in the Constitution by its framers to ensure that Congress could effectively carry out its given powers. The framers realized that they could not predict every specific situation that would require congressional action in the future. Including the Necessary and Proper Clause allowed for flexibility in lawmaking, enabling Congress to pass laws that were not expressly listed in the Constitution but were considered essential for implementing the governmental powers that were listed.
The Clause provides the legal foundation for the federal government to enact laws that are necessary to govern efficiently and address issues as they arise. This foresight by the framers facilitated the growth and adaptation of the United States government over time and contributed to the dynamism of American federalism. Additionally, the clause established a balance between maintaining the powers of the states and ensuring a strong and adaptable national government. In practice, the Clause has allowed Congress to create laws on matters such as banking regulations, minimum wage, and the construction of interstate highways, reflecting the broad scope of modern governmental responsibilities.
Learn more about Necessary and Proper Clause here:https://brainly.com/question/34187455
#SPJ12
The militaristic kaiser wilhelm forces otto von bismarck to resign in germany. T/F
Answer:
It's TRUE (T)
Explanation:
Bismarck was the one who unites Germany and had a huge influence on political affairs. However, when Wilhelm rises the power, his political views were completely different from Bismarck, especially his ideas about foreign relations, and the treatment given to opposite political groups. Plus, Bismarck knows Wilhelm since his childhood, and the Chancellor thought that could influence more. Wilhelm was advised that, in order to be a strong Kaiser, he should take Bismarck of from the political affairs. So, he forced him to resign in March 1890.
The statement is true; Kaiser Wilhelm II's divergent views on foreign policy and social reforms led to increasingly strained relations with Otto von Bismarck, who eventually resigned in 1890 due to these differences.
Explanation:The statement that Kaiser Wilhelm forced Otto von Bismarck to resign in Germany is true. Though Otto von Bismarck was a skilled statesman who effectively managed Europe's balance of power through Realpolitik, his relationship with Kaiser Wilhelm II deteriorated. Bismarck's resignation in 1890 was preceded by increasingly strained relations with the Kaiser, who had ascended to the throne in 1888 after the death of his father, Frederick III. Wilhelm II held different views on foreign policy and social reforms compared to Bismarck, who had forged Germany into a powerful empire through blood and iron, masterminding the unification of Germany.
In contrast to Bismarck's cautious diplomacy, Wilhelm II sought a more aggressive foreign policy, longing for a "place in the sun" for Germany. The Kaiser's militarism and desire for expansion would eventually contribute to the tensions leading up to World War I. When Bismarck resigned (or was dismissed), it marked the end of an era of conservative Realpolitik and the introduction of Wilhelm II's more impetuous approach to governance and international affairs. The shift in leadership styles ultimately set the stage for the pivotal events that unfolded in early 20th century Europe, including the eventual abdication of Kaiser Wilhelm II at the end of World War I and the establishment of the Weimar Republic.
The difference in growth rates between the white and black populations in the Chesapeake region in the last two decades of the 17th century can best be traced to:
Answer:
The correct answer is the growth of tobacco as a viable cash crop as the reason of the different growth rates in population.
What territories does the us gain as a result of winning the war
Answer:
The question is incomplete. This is the complete question:
What territories did the US gain as a result of winning the Spanish-American War?
The territories gained by the US included Cuba, Guam, Puerto Rico, and the Philippines
Explanation:
The Treaty of Paris (1898)—which was a treaty signed by the US and Spain, and a product of the Spanish-American War—consisted of agreements and terms of negotiation that favored the US, and allowed it to gain the territories of Cuba, Guam, Puerto Rico, and the Philippines—which, prior to the Paris treaty of 1898, were controlled by Spain. The US became a major power and player in the Pacific region after it gained these territories.
The __________ was enacted under the Balanced Budget Act of 1997, is Title XXI of the Social Security Act, and is jointly financed by federal and state funding and administered by the states. Administered by CMS, the purpose of this program is to provide coverage for low-income children younger than the age of 19 years who live above the income level requirements of Medicaid. Question
Answer:
The State´s Children Health Insurance Program
Explanation:
Which group thought that Southern states should only need to accept abolition before being readmitted to the Union?
Answer:
The radical republicans
Explanation:
From the outset of the rebellion in 1861, Lincoln’s overriding goal had been to bring the Southern states quickly back into the fold in order to restore the Union. In early December 1863, the president began the process of reunification by unveiling a three-part proposal known as the ten percent plan that outlined how the states would return. The ten percent plan gave a general pardon to all Southerners except high-ranking Confederate government and military leaders; required 10 percent of the 1860 voting population in the former rebel states to take a binding oath of future allegiance to the United States and the emancipation of slaves; and declared that once those voters took those oaths, the restored Confederate states would draft new state constitutions.
Lincoln hoped that the leniency of the plan—90 percent of the 1860 voters did not have to swear allegiance to the Union or to emancipation—would bring about a quick and long-anticipated resolution and make emancipation more acceptable everywhere. This approach appealed to some in the moderate wing of the Republican Party, which wanted to put the nation on a speedy course toward reconciliation. However, the proposal instantly drew fire from a larger faction of Republicans in Congress who did not want to deal moderately with the South. These members of Congress, known as Radical Republicans, wanted to remake the South and punish the rebels.
The group that believed Southern states should simply accept abolition before being readmitted were the followers of President Andrew Johnson, differing from Radical Republicans who sought stricter requirements.
The group that thought Southern states should only need to accept abolition before being readmitted to the Union was led by President Andrew Johnson. After the Civil War, Johnson declared that the Southern states had satisfied the necessary requirements for reentry into the Union, which primarily involved repealing the ordinances of secession and ratifying the Thirteenth Amendment.
In contrast, the Radical Republicans in Congress believed that the federal government should have a greater say in the Reconstruction process, ensuring that real Unionists controlled the process and protecting the rights of freedpeople. They did not agree with Johnson's lenient approach and insisted on setting stricter requirements for the former Confederate states’ readmission to the Union.
Stanley and Steinhardt accuse the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act of hindering what type of privacy for Americans?
Answer:
Financial privacy
Explanation:
Stanley and Steinhardt allege that the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act did the opposite of what it intended to, protect Americans' financial privacy, by authenticating the consummation of financial information by financial companies.
The Safeguards Rule of the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act requires financial institutions to develop and maintain a security plan to protect the confidentiality and integrity of personal information. According to Stanley and steinhardts the Act did the opposite, that is, hindering Americans financial privacy
The "good neighbor" polices of the 1920s and 1930s saw the United States permanently remove all its troops from Latin America.
Answer:
false
Explanation:
This statement is false
Franklin Roosevelt administration designed The Good Neighbour policy, as a way to improve relationships with Latin American governments at times where the world was just about to come to international conflict (prior to world war II)
This means that cooperation agreements and trade were stimulated in order to keep geopolitical stability in the region of Latin America.
However:
The outburst of the Mexican Revolution, and the so-called Banana Wars, among other significant conflicts, mean that American military presence in the South of the Continent was to remain.
The Russians halted their offensive near Warsaw and let the Germans massacre the Home Army, while ________.
Answer:
The Soviet Union not only refused to condemn the German action but also launched its own invasion against Poland 16 days after the Nazi attack. Similarly, Germany was silent about the attack launched against Finland by the Soviet Union, during the so-called Winter War, in December 1939. Under this pact in June 1940 the Soviet Union also annexed Estonia, Lithuania and Latvia , immediately after the German triumph in the battle of France, and simultaneously annexed territories of the Kingdom of Romania.
Explanation:
The "Manhattan Project" was the code name for the
A)U.S. plan to invade Japan.B)German use of jet aircraft.C)Allied plan to invade Europe.D)U.S. plans to make an atomic bomb.
Answer:
)U.S. plans to make an atomic bomb.
Explanation:
Answer:
Its D the whole point of the manhatan project was to gain a wepon so powerfull it can destroy a city in one go thatnks for asking btw
Oklahoma taxes which of the following goods that most other states with sales tax do not?
electronics
food
clothing
cars
In "Civil Disobedience," what does Thoreau think about right after he wonders if he could have been of service to his community?
The correct answer is B) the significance of the wall between himself and others.
The other options of the question were A) whether everyone in the town is half-witted and dull. C) that imprisoning him would not solve the problem. D) that he is truly the only person in the town to pay a tax.
In "Civil Disobedience," what Thoreau thinks about right after he wonders if he could have been of service to his community is the significance of the wall between himself and others.
As the transcendentalist, he was, Henry David Thoreau (1817-1862) supported the idea of "civil disobedience" that he applied when he refused to pay taxes and when he showed his opposition to the United States war against México. Hew though that people should resist injustice decisions and that they had the liberty to express themselves.
Answer: B
Explanation: i took the test on edge
What was the effect of Shah Abbas centralizing the government and the economy creating a powerful military, and tolerating no-Muslims?
A) The population of the capital reached over a million, but the Safavid empire declined.
B) The population of the capital reached over a million, and the Safavid empire flourished.
C)The population fell, but the Safavid empire flourished.
D) The population fell, and the Safavid empire declined.
Answer:
The correct option is B) The population of the capital reached over a million, and the Safavid empire flourished.
Explanation:
Shah Abbas was a powerful ruler of Iran who strengthened the economy by forming trade relationships between Asia and Europe.
Shah Abbas is known to strengthen the Safavid dynasty. Centralizing the government enabled Shah Abbas to revive the glory of Ancient Persia. It enabled him to establish the Safavid Empire and to dominate the Middle East. The population of the cities which he declared the capitals increased in no time.
How did the Balfour Declaration contribute to tension between Jews and Arabs?
It created the state of Israel.
It supported the establishment of a Jewish homeland in Palestine.
It created unlimited Zionist movements throughout the Middle East.
It assimilated Jews into Arab culture.
Answer:
The good answer is: It supported the establishment of a Jewish homeland in Palestine.
Explanation:
On November 2, 1917, still during the First World War, the British government made a public statement called the Balfour Declaration, in which it supported the establishment of a Jewish national home in Palestine that was by then an Ottoman territory. The declaration brought legitimacy and drew international attention to the Zionist movement.
Answer:
How did the Balfour Declaration contribute to tension between Jews and Arabs?
A) It created the state of Israel.
B) It supported the establishment of a Jewish homeland in Palestine.
C) It created unlimited Zionist movements throughout the Middle East.
D) It assimilated Jews into Arab culture.
Explanation:
the correct answer is B
PLEASE HELP I NEED IT NOW What/ who was a Catholic attempt to convince people to return to the Catholic Church
I WILL MARK YOU AS BRAINLIEST
Answer:
The counter reformation was the effort the catholic church made to defeat Protestantism and convince people to return to the church. Seminaries were schools for training protestant ministers that were set up by the council of Trent.
Explanation:
Answer:
hi there!
Explanation:
Counter-Reformation, also called Catholic Reformation or Catholic Revival, in the history of Christianity, the Roman Catholic efforts directed in the 16th and early 17th centuries both against the Protestant Reformation and toward internal renewal.
The Counter-Reformation took place during roughly the same period as the Protestant Reformation, actually beginning shortly before Martin Luther’s act of nailing the Ninety-five Theses to the door of Castle Church in 1517.
Why was the painting above so controversial?
a. The heads of the Inquisition felt it was offensive, unfocused, and blasphemous.
b. It was too realistic for some.
c. Some of the models for characters in the painting died from mysterious circumstances.
d. Jesus is not pictured in the painting.
Answer:
The question requires image but I have attached it below.
Correct answer is (a)
Explanation:
The heads of the Inquisition felt it was offensive, unfocused, and blasphemous.
Looking at the picture, one will discover that it offensive and blasphemous.
Answer:
a. The heads of the Inquisition felt it was offensive, unfocused, and blasphemous.
Explanation:
The Feast in the House of Levi by Italian painter Paolo Veronese was originally commissioned for the refectory of Santi Giovanni and Paolo as a "Last Supper" to replace a work by Titian that had been destroyed by fire in 1571.
The painting, however, attracted the attention of the Inquisition, which considered it unseemly and unholy. In addition, there was the suspicion that two Germans sitting beside Christ in the work concealed a secret Lutheran message. The painter was summoned to appear before a court and firmly repudiated the accusation of lack of decorum, as well as defended the absolute right to freedom. Despite his defense the artist was ordered to correct the composition, but refused to comply with it and eventually changed the name of the work.
The immense painting is characteristic of Venetian Renaissance art in the use of classical architecture, deep perspective, rich colors and careful observation of details. The work evokes the splendor, magnificence and light of Venetian life
What are the positive aspects of keynesian economics?
Answer: The positive aspect of keynesian economics are
1.) Higher Employment Levels
2.) Stabilization of the Banking Industry.
3.) Tighter Control on Government Spending. ...
4.) New Tools to Monitor a Country's Economic Output
5.) Moderation of Interest Rates.
Explanation:
The Keynesian theory is an macro-economic theory that advocated for an increased government expenditures (spending) and lowering of taxes for stimulation of demand for getting an economy out of the depression.
If the Keynesian policy are adopted, then, an economy will experience some positive aspect which includes:
Higher Employment LevelsStabilization of the Banking IndustryTighter Control on Government SpendingNew Tools to Monitor a Country's Economic OutputModeration of Interest Rates
Read more about Keynesian theory
brainly.com/question/6505999
Between 1995 and 2004 the cases of serial murder _____.
a. sharply inclined
b. sharply declined
c. stayed the same as before 1975
d. rose only a little
Answer:
The correct answe is option B: Sharply declined is what happen between 1995 and 2004 in the case of a serial murder.
Explanation:
In the 1970s and 80s there was a rise of serial murders in the United States as they were first being discovered as serial killers and people were investigating the psycology of those people.
The first colonization efforts undertaken by the English in the New World were largely the schemes of
Answer:
Private Individuals
Explanation:
The first colonization undertaken by the English in the New World largely arranged by private Individuals like Sir Walter Raleigh. He made two attempts to establish a colony but failed to do so because of the harsh climate, hostile Indians, diseases, and hunger. The governors including Ralph Lane and John White, under the responsibility for settling permanent settlement. At last in 1607, Jamestown became the first permanent English settlement in America. The colony set up by the Plymouth Company and the London Company after getting charters from King James I.
What year was the first presidential news conference and who was the president
Answer: The answer is:
Woodrow Wilson
Explanation:
In March 1913, In March 1913, Woodrow Wilson began the first regular US presidential press conferences. By modern standards, they were a strange, awkward affair. began the first regular US presidential press conferences.
Since 1973, the poverty rate for Americans over 65 has fallen, while it has increased for Americans under 18. An important reason for this is that:
A) older Americans are reluctant to retire, and they are taking jobs away from the younger generation
B) spending on programs that benefit the elderly (such as Social Security and Medicare) has increased, while aid to families with children has not kept up with inflation
C) a very small fraction of the population under age 18 lives with people over 65
D) most people under age 18 are unmarried and therefore have access to only one income
Answer:
(B) spending on programs that benefit the elderly (such as Social Security and Medicare) has increased, while aid to families with children has not kept up with inflation
Explanation:
Since 1973 the poverty rate for people 65 or older has fallen dramatically. This drop could be ascribed to the enactment of the Medicare Program in 1965, which dramatically lowered out-of-pocket health care costs for this age group.
The major indicators of poverty in the United states are less education for impoverished families, more health problems and less access to nutritionally adequate food. They also are more likely to live in high-crime areas. Since 1973 government has taken measures to reduce this tendency to porverty for those aged 65 and above, by enacting programs. These has led to the poverty percentage for those at that age bracket to reduce the poverty rate for teenagers it has increased.
The executions of sacco and vanzetti in the 1920s demonstrated the
Answer:
Increase in Nativist attitudes.
Explanation:
Italian immigrants Nicola Sacco and Bartolomeo Vanzetti in 1920 attempted robbery at a shoe factory and murdered two people. Both were put on trial and executed. The outcome of the executions resulted in nativist attitudes toward working-class immigrants. The immigrants ruined their reputation after the capture of both the Italian men because they believed to be the destroyer of American society through anarchists.
The executions of Nicola Sacco and Bartolomeo Vanzetti during the 1920s demonstrated the significant fear and anxiety over immigration and radical politics in the United States during that time period. Their trial and execution highlighted the nativist sentiments and fear of radical politics prevalent in society.
Explanation:The executions of Nicola Sacco and Bartolomeo Vanzetti in the 1920s demonstrated the widespread fear and anxiety over immigration, particularly of those with radical political beliefs, in the United States during this era. Sacco and Vanzetti were Italian immigrants who were accused of a robbery and murder, with no direct evidence linking them to the crime. Both men were, however, known as anarchists, which was emphasized during their trial and ultimately led to their conviction and execution.
Their trial and execution sparked worldwide protests and was widely viewed as a gross miscarriage of justice, particularly among immigrant and intellectual communities. The case effectively underscored the deep-seated nativist sentiments and fear of radical politics in the United States during the 1920s.
Learn more about Sacco and Vanzetti Executions here:https://brainly.com/question/12564399
#SPJ12
In the Compromise of 1850, Congress determined that slavery in the New Mexico and Utah territories was a) to be banned b) protected by federal law c) to be decided by popular sovereignty d) to be ignored until either territory applied for admission to statehood e) to be decided by the Mormon Church
Taking into account the statement above:
"In the Compromise of 1850, Congress determined that slavery in the New Mexico and Utah territories was a) to be banned b) protected by federal law c) to be decided by popular sovereignty d) to be ignored until either territory applied for admission to statehood e) to be decided by the Mormon Church"
The answer is: c) to be decided by popular sovereignty.
Also, cultural & history was anti-slavery.
Hope this helps.
Why were limes grown only in Florida prior to the decline of the industry?
Other regions could not compete with Florida’s prices.
Limes are especially prone to disease.
There was little demand for limes.
Florida has the only climate that could grow limes.
Answer:
Florida has the only climate that could grow limes.
Explanation:
Limes were predominantly grown in Florida due to the region's unique climate, which was particularly suitable for lime cultivation and not present in other parts of the United States, leading to higher productivity and cost efficiency.
Limes were grown only in Florida prior to the industry decline mainly because Florida has the only climate that could grow limes effectively.
The climate in Florida was highly suitable for lime cultivation, which is why it became a specialized crop area. Specialized crop areas occur where local soil and climate conditions allow farmers to grow certain crops that are very profitable, often because these crops cannot grow well in many other locations. This creates a low supply and high demand situation, potentially leading to higher prices. Climate and disease resistance also play pivotal roles in the success of lime growing in Florida. While there was certainly a demand for limes, Florida's unique climate conditions positioned it as a predominant source prior to the industry decline, unlike regions where climate or diseases hindered profitable lime cultivation.
Florida's specialization in lime cultivation was principally due to its unique climate suitable for lime growth, which was not replicated elsewhere in the United States. Therefore, other regions could not compete with Florida in terms of productivity and cost efficiency for lime production.
Under Czar Nicholas II, Russian laws banned ____________and___________ . In addition, the czar’s guards opened fire at a peaceful demonstration of protestors, resulting in _____________.
1. Progroms, Secret Police, or Workers' Strikes
2. Nationalism, Censorship, or Trade Unions
3. Bloody Sunday or Decembrist Revolt
NEED HELP QUICK!!!!!!!
Answer:
OK WAIT
Explanation:
WAIT
Which of these is not a main advantage for a business joining a cooperative?
lay and collect taxes and duties
pay debts
regulate American Indian groups
regulate commerce inside a state
borrow money
regulate commerce with foreign nations
Answer: 1,2,5,6
Answer:
Since joining a cooperative grants to its members economic advantages such as dividends, tax reduction, funding opportunities, the improvement of products and services, reduction of costs and continuity of the business, and although the state and/or governmet provide some assistance, the busness or cooperative do not become a regulator itself or a governmental entity;
thereby the options not considered advantages would be: 1,3,4&6, but paying debts & borrowing money are included as advantages though.
Which of the following was one of many important factors in encouraging the expeditions of the late fifteenth century?
A. Competition among European monarchs
B. An economic crisis in Europe
C. Religious disillusionment and frustration with the church
D. The lack of natural resources in Europe and the need to find alternative sources
Answer:
A. Competition among European monarchs
Explanation:
The European Age of Exploration developed alongside the Renaissance. Both periods in Western history acted as transitional moments between the Middle Ages and the early modern period. Competition between burgeoning European empires, such as Spain and Enhland, fueled the evolution and advancement of overseas exploration. Motivated by religion, profit , and power, the size and influence of European empires during this period expanded greatly. The effects of exploration were not only felt abroad but also within the geographic confines of Europe itself. The economic, political, and cultural effects of Europe's beginning stages of global exploration impacted the longterm development of both European society and the entire world.
Final answer:
The expeditions of the late fifteenth century were majorly encouraged by the competition among European monarchs looking for new sources of wealth, prestige, and power, as well as by religious motivations to spread Christianity and rivalries resulting from the Protestant Reformation.
Explanation:
One of the many important factors in encouraging the expeditions of the late fifteenth century was A. Competition among European monarchs. This period was characterized by a quest for new resources, territories, and prestige among the European powers. Factors such as the desire for god, glory, and gold spurred rulers to assert dominance and expand their realms, which was often achieved through exploration and the establishment of colonies.
The exploration was also driven by a need to find new trade routes, as Europeans sought to circumvent existing ones controlled by others and gain direct access to the wealth of Asia and the New World. The competition among monarchs intensified as national wealth became synonymous with power, and resources from new lands could give a distinct advantage over rivals.
Furthermore, religious motives also catalyzed these expeditions, especially in the context of the Catholic nations wishing to spread Christianity and the emerging Protestant Reformation, leading to inter-religious rivalries that extended into colonial ambitions.
Given what you know about households, which following statements is most applicable with regards to the European family structure in the 18th century?
Answer:
European family structure in Eastern Europe was stronger than Northwestern Europe.
Explanation:
European family structure in the 18th century was unique in its period. Industrialization changes the society and life of people. In the Eastern European family, grandparents were much more respected and had the opportunity to form a bond with their grandchildren than did Northwestern European. A society based on the values of the old traditions in Eastern Europe where Northwestern Europe believed in the nuclear family as they were heading towards capitalism.
A major 1986 survey of journalists attributed liberal bias in traditional media to what factor?
A. journalistic norms
B. market competition
C. liberal leanings of the journalists themselves
D. reliance on previous reporting
The correct answer is C) liberal leanings of the journalists themselves.
A major 1986 survey of journalists attributed liberal bias in traditional media to the following factor: liberal leanings of the journalists themselves.
The liberal studies and concepts learned in college were one of the motives of the liberal bias in traditional media in the United States. Let's have in mind that one of the requisites of the goof journalist is to never bias the information. Totally the opposite, they always have to maintain objectivity because their credibility is at risk is the audience know they are trying to manipulate the news.
Final answer:
The major 1986 survey on journalists indicated that perceived liberal bias in media was attributed to the journalists' own liberal leanings, despite norms of objectivity in journalism meant to mitigate such influences.
Explanation:
The 1986 survey of journalists attributed the perception of liberal bias in traditional media primarily to the liberal leanings of the journalists themselves.
While journalists are trained and ethically bound to strive for objectivity—reporting accurately, impartially, and without distortion—personal biases can sometimes inadvertently influence coverage. These leanings are a reflection of the journalists' individual backgrounds, experiences, and views.
However, it's also important to recognize the potential influence of media owners who may possess conservative biases, though this influence is generally felt less directly in the reporting process.
The norms of objectivity intrinsic to American journalism are meant to keep personal biases in check, although criticisms such as false balance can arise when controversial issues are reported without adequately reflecting the weight of evidence.
How do countries protect their domestic economy from excessive influence by multinational corporations?
a. by raising the price of goods provided by the multinationalsb. by developing their internal economiesc. by limiting the supplies of the multinational corporationd. by requiring the multinational to export a certain percentage of its product
Answer:
a. by raising the price of goods provided by the multinationals
Explanation:
The relationships between multinational companies and the governments of countries (mostly emerging) are complex. This is because the large multinationals usually seek the maximization of their economic benefits and profits, while the governments of these countries seek the maximization of the added value that the multinational activity can leave them, especially that which remains within The borders of the country.
Answer
Explanation:
internal economiesc. by limiting the supplies of the multinational corporationd. by requiring the multinational to export a certain percentage of its product